Luke Reviews


X-Men: Legacy - Divided He Stands

Posted by Luke Forney on August 20, 2010 at 7:25 PM

X-Men: Messiah CompleX changed a lot. The team’s old headquarters were destroyed, and they made a major move to a new home in Uncanny X-Men: Divided We Stand. However, even more changed for Professor X. His story is found in the newly-re-titled X-Men: Legacy, the first volume of which is X-Men: Legacy – Divided He Stands.


After what should have been a fatal injury at the end of Messiah CompleX, Xavier is on the brink of death when he is rescued by, of all people, the villain Exodus. Exodus uses his powers to repair Xavier’s broken body, but he needs the help of Xavier’s long-time friend and archenemy Magneto to repair Xavier’s fractured mind. And just as that situation seems to be resolved, Xavier discovers a dark secret buried in his past.


X-Men: Legacy – Divided He Stands contains: X-Men: Legacy #208 (“From Genesis to Revelations” ) , #209 (From Genesis to Revelations, Part Two” ) , #210 (“From Genesis to Revelations, Part Three” ) , #211 (“Sins of the Father, Part One” ) , #212 (“Sins of the Father, Part Two” ) .


While X-Men: Legacy isn’t the action fest that Uncanny X-Men is, Mike Carey’s story is incredibly gripping, as he weaves huge amounts of the X-Men’s and Xavier’s past into the story. Xavier’s quest to save his mind and rediscover his memories is one that leads to a lot of dark places in X-Men history, and each is explored in a wonderful tapestry that all fits back together into the frame narrative.


There is plenty of character exploration, and lots and background. The story is an excellent character piece about Xavier, and what he went through and accomplished as head of the X-Men, both good and bad. Solid work.


Things that might perturb readers: The story is definitely continuity-heavy, so some new readers may not get all of the references. This isn’t necessary to enjoy the story, but it may still bother some. Also, while all volumes of X-Men are part of a larger story, and those no true, definite “end” is ever there, the wrapping up of the current story provides that end piece. This volume ends mid story, so it isn’t the best for those looking for a one-and-done book.



Categories: None

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In



If you would like to email Luke, he can be reached at lukehf (AT) , just replace the (AT) with @ . Luke would love to hear from you!

Help Luke Reviews Continue to Provide Reviews of New Books!

Luke Reviews on Facebook!

Come check out Luke Reviews on Facebook, become a fan, and follow links to new reviews! It is just in the opening stages, but more and more will go up as time progresses. Can't wait to see you there!

The NEW Rating System

10: One of the best books of the year. A must read. Worth reading again.


9: An excellent book. One that I would pick up again, but is missing that “x-factor” to make it a full 10.


8: A lot of fun to read, and recommended.


7: A good book.


6: Above average, but not by much.


5: An average book.


4: Below average, but not by much.


3: A sub-par book. Deeply disappointing.


2: Got halfway but couldn’t finish.


1: Couldn’t get halfway.