Luke Reviews


Bad Cop, No Donut edited by John L. French

Posted by Luke Forney on October 12, 2010 at 4:53 PM

NOTE: Bad Cop, No Donut was a free review copy provided to Luke Reviews by Dark Quest Books.


I read some mystery and crime fiction on occasion, but not often, and not nearly as much as I would like. Especially rare are original crime anthologies. So, when I received Bad Cop, No Donut, I dove at the chance to explore some new crime stories from the darker side of the genre.


What I found in Bad Cop, No Donut was a buffet of stories that were even better than expected. Editor John L. French’s “The Last Convention” was exciting from first word to last. C. J. Henderson’s “A Fine Officer” is up to his usual high standards as well.


However, there were two that really took the cake. Patrick Thomas’ “Dysmayed” took the “bad cop” theme straight to Hell, literally, with the return of his series character of Hell’s Detective.


The best of the batch, though, was the volume opener, James Chambers’ “Henkin’s Last Lies.” His characters felt perfectly real, the motivations true, and the plot twists were as believable as they were effective.


Not to say that there was a truly bad story in the bunch. You would be hard-pressed to find a new anthology out there that has as high a level of quality as this one. So if you are a fan of the rough side of crime fiction, of cops gone wrong, and noir fiction, give Bad Cop, No Donut a shot.

Categories: None

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In



If you would like to email Luke, he can be reached at lukehf (AT) , just replace the (AT) with @ . Luke would love to hear from you!

Help Luke Reviews Continue to Provide Reviews of New Books!

Luke Reviews on Facebook!

Come check out Luke Reviews on Facebook, become a fan, and follow links to new reviews! It is just in the opening stages, but more and more will go up as time progresses. Can't wait to see you there!

The NEW Rating System

10: One of the best books of the year. A must read. Worth reading again.


9: An excellent book. One that I would pick up again, but is missing that “x-factor” to make it a full 10.


8: A lot of fun to read, and recommended.


7: A good book.


6: Above average, but not by much.


5: An average book.


4: Below average, but not by much.


3: A sub-par book. Deeply disappointing.


2: Got halfway but couldn’t finish.


1: Couldn’t get halfway.